# event-system.md — Review Log

## Review — 2026-04-30 — Verdict: APPROVED (second review — all blocking items addressed in-session)
**Scope signal**: S
**Specialists**: lean review
**Blocking items**: 0 (all 2 addressed: Pillar placeholder defined; Node System dependency updated to Approved)
**Recommended revisions**: 1 (OQ1 stale — now resolved: 1 Event node at position 6 per Plain theme)
**Summary**: Second review verified both blocking items from first review addressed in-session. Event System is technically thorough — deterministic seeding, working-copy commit pattern, seeded random chain, and edge case coverage are all well-specified. Core architecture is sound and implementable. Pillar defined as "narrative surprise and meaningful stakes." OQ1 updated to RESOLVED confirming exactly 1 Event node per run at position 6.
**Prior verdict resolved**: Yes — Pillar and stale dependency both fixed.

## Review — 2026-04-30 — Verdict: NEEDS REVISION (first review)
**Scope signal**: S
**Specialists**: lean review
**Blocking items**: 2 | **Recommended**: 1
**Summary**: First review found 2 blocking items: (1) Status header Pillar is a placeholder "[To be designed]"; (2) Stale Node System dependency status (shows "Designed" but is Approved). Recommended: OQ1 is now answerable since Node System is Approved — exactly 1 Event node at position 6 in Plain theme. All other aspects (deterministic seeding, working copy commit, edge cases, AC coverage) are solid.
**Prior verdict resolved**: N/A (first review)