Vampire-Act-Base/design/gdd/form-switch-state-machine.md

Form Switch State Machine

Status: In Review (revised 2026-04-27 — addressed 6 blocking review findings) Author: SepComet + Claude Last Updated: 2026-04-27 Implements Pillar: 形态即战术 (Form is Tactics), 切换即承诺 (Switch is Commitment)

Overview

Form Switch State Machine 是夜裔最核心的战斗系统——管理玩家在三种形态（人形、狼躯、雾形）之间的切换。每次切换不是一个即时操作，而是一个有节奏的承诺：玩家按下切换键后，必须经过短暂的 Windup 前摇（0.25s，期间可被打断），然后进入 Switching 无敌帧（0.10s），最后 Recovery 后摇（0.15s）和冷却（0.3s）。总间隔 ≥ 0.8s，其中 Windup 是风险窗口——被打断则血能不退。状态机结构遵循 ADR-004 的 4 阶段设计。切换不仅改变攻击风格（通过 AttackStyle 传递给 Combat Logic），还改变移动方式和视觉呈现。这个系统是"切换即承诺"和"形态即战术"两个核心支柱的直接实现。

Player Fantasy

形态切换不是按个键换色——它是你在战场上读秒的瞬间。当一群 Swarm 杂兵围上来时，你在心里计时：Windup 0.25 秒是否安全？切到雾形后能否在 Recovery 结束前按下第一次攻击？每一次成功切换都让你感觉自己"掌握了一种危险的古老力量"——你能变成雾穿透敌阵、变成狼撕裂目标、变回人形精准弹反。在外人看来，你在一群敌人中间跳舞；在你自己看来，你在做一连串以秒为单位的战术决策。参考 RE4 弹反"接住时机"的释放感和 DMC 形态切换的流畅感，但加入风险——我们的切换会失败，失败有代价，这才是"切换即承诺"。

Detailed Design

Core Rules

1. Switch Request: Player presses form key → RequestSwitch(targetForm)

• Checks CanSwitchTo(target): Phase=Idle ✓, cooldown ended ✓, blood energy sufficient ✓, target≠current ✓
• Returns: SwitchResult.Success / InsufficientEnergy / OnCooldown / InvalidTarget
• Blood Energy Economy is injected via constructor (IBloodEnergyEconomy interface) — follows project DI standard. RequestSwitch takes only FormType target.

SwitchResult enum:

SwitchResult { Success, InsufficientEnergy, OnCooldown, InvalidTarget }

2. State Machine Flow:

Idle →(RequestSwitch)→ Windup(0.25s) →(timer)→ Switching(0.10s) →(timer)→ Recovery(0.15s) →(timer)→ Idle(+0.3s cooldown)
                              │                                                                     │
                              └─ Hit → Interrupt() → Idle (energy spent, NOT refunded)             └─ RequestSwitch now available

3. Phase Capability Limits:

Phase	Move	Attack	Damaged	Re-Switch	Visual
Idle	✓	✓	✓	✓	Current form normal
Windup	✓ (50% slow)	✗	✓	✗	Form flicker, color transition begins
Switching	✗	✗	✗ (i-frames)	✗	Geometry restructure animation
Recovery	✓	✓	✗	✗	New form color stabilizing

4. Cooldown: After Recovery, extra 0.3s before next switch allowed. Windup(0.25) + Switching(0.10) + Recovery(0.15) + Cooldown(0.30) = 0.80s minimum between switches.

Cooldown state note: During cooldown, Phase reports Idle (the player can move and attack freely). Systems must query CanSwitchTo(target) — not Phase — to determine switch availability. CanSwitchTo() checks: Phase=Idle AND cooldown expired AND energy sufficient AND target≠current. Phase alone does not imply switch-readiness.

Attack Style Output

Form	AttackStyle	Consumer
Human	{Shape: Sector(100°,3.0), BaseDamage:18, CritChanceStat:0.05, CritMultiplier:1.5, KnockbackForce:5, AttackSpeed:0.4s, MaxTargets:1}	Combat Logic
Wolf	{Shape: Rect(1.0,5.0), BaseDamage:22, CritChanceStat:0.05, CritMultiplier:1.5, KnockbackForce:8, AttackSpeed:0.6s, MaxTargets:3}	Combat Logic
Mist	{Shape: Circle(3.8), BaseDamage:8, CritChanceStat:0.05, CritMultiplier:1.5, KnockbackForce:3, AttackSpeed:0.8s, MaxTargets:20}	Combat Logic

Canonical source: All AttackStyle values are owned by Combat Logic GDD (Approved). Form Switch SM stores and provides these values at runtime via GetAttackStyle(CurrentForm). If values diverge, Combat Logic is authoritative. CritChanceStat, CritMultiplier, and KnockbackForce were added per Combat Logic GDD contract note (revised 2026-04-27). Range removed — attack range is derived from HitShape (Circle.Radius for Mist, Rect.Length for Wolf, Sector.Radius for Human).

Interactions with Other Systems

System	Direction	Interface
Blood Energy Economy	Upstream	Calls CanSpend(cost), Spend(cost) on successful switch
Player Input	Upstream	Responds to OnSwitchPress(FormType) events from Input Adapter
Combat Logic	Downstream	Provides GetAttackStyle(CurrentForm) for hit resolution
VFX Spawner (L1)	Downstream	Emits OnFormChanged, OnPhaseChanged, OnSwitchInterrupted
UI/HUD (L2)	Downstream	OnFormChanged drives HUD form indicator update
Skill Tree	Upstream	Can modify WindupDuration, CooldownDuration, unlock new forms

Event ordering contract: When a switch completes (Recovery→Idle), events fire in this order: (1) OnFormChanged(from, to), (2) OnPhaseChanged(Idle). When Interrupt() is called during Windup: (1) OnSwitchInterrupted(targetForm), (2) OnPhaseChanged(Idle). During normal phase transitions (Windup→Switching→Recovery): only OnPhaseChanged fires. Subscribers (VFX, Audio, HUD) can rely on this ordering.

Dependency injection: IBloodEnergyEconomy is injected via constructor. RequestSwitch(FormType target) takes only the target form — it internally calls _energy.CanSpend(cost) and _energy.Spend(cost). This follows the project DI-over-singletons standard and allows mock injection for L0 testing.

Formulas

No complex formulas. Core timing relationships:

totalSwitchTime = WindupDuration + SwitchDuration + RecoveryDuration  (= 0.50s default)
minSwitchInterval = totalSwitchTime + CooldownDuration               (= 0.80s default)

The timing parameters are tunable (see Tuning Knobs). The WindupDuration is the critical feel variable — it creates the "danger window" that defines the Switch is Commitment pillar.

Edge Cases

#	Condition	Resolution
1	RequestSwitch while Phase≠Idle	Return OnCooldown — only Idle accepts input
2	RequestSwitch to current form	Return InvalidTarget — meaningless switch
3	Hit during Windup	Interrupt() → Phase=Idle, energy already spent, NOT refunded
4	Hit during Switching	Ignored — i-frames are absolute
5	Die during any phase	Force reset to Idle, CurrentForm=Human, energy already at 0
6	skillDiscount makes switchCost→0	Minimum cost 1.0 enforced (from Blood Energy GDD)
7	Switch key held down (repeated input)	Ignored — only rising edge triggers RequestSwitch
8	deltaTime=0 (pause)	Skip Update(), state frozen
9	WindupDuration reduced to 0 by Skill Tree	Clamp to minimum 0.10s floor — Skill Tree cannot reduce WindupDuration below 0.10s
10	Cooldown reduced to 0 by Skill Tree	Clamp to minimum 0.15s floor — Skill Tree cannot reduce CooldownDuration below 0.15s
11	Damage during Windup exactly as timer expires	Switching wins — damage ignored (favor the player at boundaries). Implementation: within a single Update() call, the phase timer is decremented FIRST, then damage is processed.
12	Multiple switch requests in same frame	Only first processed
13	deltaTime exceeds WindupDuration (frame spike)	Clamp effective deltaTime to min(deltaTime, WindupDuration) — process at most one phase transition per Update() call
14	Skill Tree modifies timing param mid-switch	Snapshot at RequestSwitch — changes apply on next switch, not mid-transition
15	Switch input buffered during last 0.10s of Recovery	Queued input auto-executes when cooldown expires. Buffer holds exactly one input (most recent wins).

Dependencies

System	Relationship	Hard/Soft
Blood Energy Economy (Approved)	Upstream — must check/spend energy	Hard
Player Input (undesigned)	Upstream — input events	Hard
Combat Logic (Designed)	Downstream — provides AttackStyle per form	Hard
VFX Spawner (undesigned)	Downstream — visual events	Soft
UI/HUD (undesigned)	Downstream — form indicator	Soft
Skill Tree (undesigned)	Upstream — modifies timing parameters	Soft

Provisional assumption: Player Input provides OnSwitchPress(FormType) events. The Form-to-key mapping (Human=1, Wolf=2, Mist=3 or similar) is defined in the Input Adapter GDD.

Tuning Knobs

Parameter	Default	Safe Range	Core Impact
WindupDuration	0.25s	0.15–0.35s	The "danger window" — defines switch feel
SwitchDuration	0.10s	0.05–0.15s	I-frame generosity
RecoveryDuration	0.15s	0.10–0.25s	Re-entry smoothness after switch
CooldownDuration	0.30s	0.15–0.50s	Switch rhythm spacing
WindupSlowPercent	0.50	0.30–0.70	Mobility during Windup
Human BaseDamage	18	10–25	Human form reward
Wolf BaseDamage	22	15–35	Wolf form reward
Mist BaseDamage	8	4–15	Mist form reward

Key interaction: Reducing WindupDuration + CooldownDuration too aggressively removes the tactical weight of switching. Hard floors enforced: WindupDuration ≥ 0.10s, CooldownDuration ≥ 0.15s, keeping total interval ≥ 0.40s (0.10+0.05+0.10+0.15). Skill Tree upgrades reduce toward these floors but never below them.

Visual/Audio Requirements

Combat system — Visual/Audio is REQUIRED.

VFX (via L1 VFX Spawner):

• OnFormChanged(from, to): Geometric burst at player position — color = new form color
• OnPhaseChanged(Windup): Form flicker + color lerp from current to target
• OnPhaseChanged(Switching): Geometry warp/restructure + brief i-frame glow (white)
• OnSwitchInterrupted: Red flash + particle scatter in current form color

Audio (via L1 Audio Player):

• OnFormChanged: Distinct form activation SFX per form (Human=sharp, Wolf=heavy, Mist=ethereal)
• OnPhaseChanged(Windup): Rising tension drone
• OnSwitchInterrupted: Dissonant "snap" — clear audio punishment

Art Bible Alignment: Principle 1 (Color is Identity — switch VFX color directly communicates new form), Principle 3 (Particles are Feedback — each phase has a unique particle signature).

UI Requirements

Element	Content
Form Indicator	3 form icons — current highlighted, out-of-reach greyed, available glowing
Switch Cooldown Ring	Circular timer showing remaining cooldown around form indicator
Phase Feedback	Windup = red border flash (danger), Switching = gold border (i-frames)
Switch Failure Feedback	InsufficientEnergy = energy bar flash red; OnCooldown = cooldown ring pulse; InvalidTarget = current form icon pulse (already active)
Buffered Switch Indicator	When switch input is queued during Recovery buffer: form icon shows subtle glow/border pulse to confirm input was registered

Acceptance Criteria

Testing scope: ACs marked [L0] are NUnit-testable without Unity. ACs marked [L1] require Unity integration testing. ACs marked [VISUAL] require manual sign-off.

State Machine Transitions [L0]

#	GIVEN	WHEN	THEN
1	Phase=Idle, energy≥cost, WindupDuration=0.25	RequestSwitch(Wolf)	Phase→Windup, PhaseTimer=WindupDuration
2	Phase=Windup, PhaseTimer=0	Update(dt)	Phase→Switching, PhaseTimer=SwitchDuration
3	Phase=Switching, PhaseTimer=0	Update(dt)	Phase→Recovery, PhaseTimer=RecoveryDuration
4	Phase=Recovery, PhaseTimer=0	Update(dt)	Phase→Idle, CooldownTimer=CooldownDuration. Phase reports Idle; CanSwitchTo() returns false until cooldown expires.
5	Phase=Idle, CooldownTimer=0.05	Update(0.06)	CooldownTimer=0, CanSwitchTo() returns true (energy permitting)

Switch Validation [L0]

#	GIVEN	WHEN	THEN
6	Phase=Idle, CooldownTimer=0.1 remaining	RequestSwitch(Wolf)	Returns SwitchResult.OnCooldown, Phase stays Idle
7	Phase=Idle, energy < switchCost	RequestSwitch(Wolf)	Returns SwitchResult.InsufficientEnergy, Phase stays Idle, energy unchanged
8	CurrentForm=Human	RequestSwitch(Human)	Returns SwitchResult.InvalidTarget, Phase stays Idle
9	Phase=Switching	RequestSwitch(Wolf)	Returns SwitchResult.OnCooldown (only Idle accepts input)

Interrupt & Damage [L0]

#	GIVEN	WHEN	THEN
10	Phase=Windup, energy deducted by Spend(cost) on switch start	Interrupt()	Phase→Idle, energy NOT refunded (verify mock IBloodEnergyEconomy.Refund() was NOT called), OnSwitchInterrupted fires with target form
11	Phase=Switching	Hit received / Interrupt()	Ignored — Phase stays Switching, no events fire
12	Phase=Recovery	Hit received	Ignored — Phase stays Recovery
13	Phase=Windup, PhaseTimer≤PHASE_EPSILON (0.001), hit received same frame	Update(dt) then damage check	Phase→Switching before damage processed — hit ignored (player-favored boundary)

AttackStyle Output [L0]

#	GIVEN	WHEN	THEN
14	CurrentForm=Human	GetAttackStyle()	Returns Shape=Sector(100°,3.0), BaseDamage=18, CritChanceStat=0.05, CritMultiplier=1.5, KnockbackForce=5, AttackSpeed=0.4s, MaxTargets=1
15	CurrentForm=Wolf	GetAttackStyle()	Returns Shape=Rect(1.0,5.0), BaseDamage=22, CritChanceStat=0.05, CritMultiplier=1.5, KnockbackForce=8, AttackSpeed=0.6s, MaxTargets=3
16	CurrentForm=Mist	GetAttackStyle()	Returns Shape=Circle(3.8), BaseDamage=8, CritChanceStat=0.05, CritMultiplier=1.5, KnockbackForce=3, AttackSpeed=0.8s, MaxTargets=20

Events [L0]

#	GIVEN	WHEN	THEN
17	Switch completes (Recovery→Idle), Human→Wolf	OnFormChanged	Event fires with args (Human, Wolf). Fires BEFORE OnPhaseChanged(Idle).
18	Phase transitions Idle→Windup	Phase change	OnPhaseChanged fires with (Windup) after OnFormChanged (if form changed)
19	Phase transitions Windup→Switching	Phase change	OnPhaseChanged fires with (Switching)
20	Phase transitions Switching→Recovery	Phase change	OnPhaseChanged fires with (Recovery)
21	Phase transitions Recovery→Idle	Phase change	OnPhaseChanged fires with (Idle)
22	Interrupt() called during Windup	Interrupt	OnSwitchInterrupted fires with targetForm (the form being switched to)

Phase Capability Queries [L0]

#	GIVEN	WHEN	THEN
23	Phase=Windup	CanMove() queried	Returns true. GetMovementSpeedMultiplier() returns WindupSlowPercent (0.50).
24	Phase=Windup	CanAttack() queried	Returns false
25	Phase=Switching	CanMove() queried	Returns false
26	Phase=Switching	CanBeDamaged() queried	Returns false (i-frames)
27	Phase=Recovery	CanBeDamaged() queried	Returns false

Edge Case Coverage [L0]

#	GIVEN	WHEN	THEN
28	WindupDuration=0.10 (floor), Phase=Idle, energy≥cost	RequestSwitch(Wolf) + Update(dt)	Phase→Switching (Windup skipped at floor value). PhaseTimer=SwitchDuration.
29	CooldownDuration=0.15 (floor), Recovery→Idle transition	Update(dt)	CooldownTimer=0.15. CanSwitchTo() returns false until cooldown expires.
30	Phase=Windup, Die() called	Death during switch	Force reset: Phase=Idle, CurrentForm=Human. Energy NOT refunded.
31	deltaTime=0.0	Update(0)	Phase unchanged, PhaseTimer unchanged, no events fire
32	deltaTime=0.3 (exceeds WindupDuration=0.25)	Update(0.3)	Effective dt clamped to WindupDuration — at most one phase transition. Phase→Switching, PhaseTimer=SwitchDuration.
33	Two RequestSwitch(Wolf) calls in same frame (before Update)	Sequential calls	First returns Success (Phase→Windup). Second returns OnCooldown (Phase≠Idle).

Input Buffering [L0]

#	GIVEN	WHEN	THEN
34	Phase=Recovery, RecoveryTimer≤0.10 (within buffer window)	RequestSwitch(Wolf)	Input queued. When Recovery→Idle and cooldown expires, queued switch auto-executes.
35	Two different form requests buffered during same Recovery window	RequestSwitch(Wolf) then RequestSwitch(Mist)	Only most recent (Mist) is queued — buffer holds one input.
36	Phase=Idle, cooldown active, RecoveryTimer already 0 (outside buffer window)	RequestSwitch(Wolf)	Returns SwitchResult.OnCooldown — NOT buffered. Buffer only active during last 0.10s of Recovery.

Open Questions

• Should the player be able to buffer a switch request during Recovery (auto-execute after cooldown)? — Yes: implement a 0.10s buffer window at the end of Recovery. Any switch input during the last 0.10s of Recovery is queued and auto-executes when the cooldown expires. Short enough to require timing, long enough to prevent dropped-input frustration. The buffer holds exactly one input (most recent wins).
• Should Windup slow use a configurable curve (linear vs ease-in)? — MVP uses linear; revisit for polish.
• Should the architecture support a 4th form in the future? — Yes, FormType enum is extensible. Skill Tree GDD should reserve an expansion node.